The remark Walter Harris must be referring to was made by me at a UPT meeting last spring (April 18, I believe) at which Walter Harris himself was not present. My concern at the time was to include education in the deliberations and reports.
The meeting was held during the 9 days we had to give feedback on the Pathways plan. We were discussing the SCAP report on the plan. I pointed out that the SCAP report endorsed eliminating the education department and reinstated broadcast communications and computer science. However, while there were representatives of both broadcast journalism and the math & computer science departments on the SCAP committee, there was no one from education. I pointed this out and said that if they wanted to be taken seriously, they needed to include someone from education. I was arguing for the inclusion of education, and asking that education be included in the future. I basically did not want Loyola to eliminate the education department. I was also afraid that if they did not include education, their report could be more easily dismissed as self-serving. Members of the SCAP committee present at the UPT explained that their committee was formed quickly from the available members of SCAP who could stay in town and spend their Easter holidays working and that no one from education was a member of SCAP. They did not purposely exclude education; education was simply not represented on SCAP and therefore was not even there when they put their committee together. They also agreed that education should be included. And I think that they did follow up on that, because I know Marge Dermody was included in some future meetings.
After making those remarks and since time was running out in the very narrow window in which anyone could give feedback on Pathways, I also asked UPT if that committee wanted to do our own report on the Pathways plan. The committee basically liked the SCAP report and decided to accept and endorse the SCAP report. Thus the SCAP report was endorsed by the UPT, a university-wide committee, not a narrow self-interested group.
Overall, I have serious difficulties with being quoted out of context by someone who was not even there, did not hear what I said, and was not part of the conversation about why I said it.
Thanks for letting me know about this. Feel free to share my comments with others.
|